Sunday, January 31, 2010

CCSVI and MS Conference in Hamilton

On February 7th, a week from today, Drs. Zamboni, Simka, Dake and Haacke (and others) will be presenting results of their research and clinical experience in a conference at St. Joseph's Hospital in Hamilton, Ontario.  Of particular interest will be the preliminary results of the study of 500 people conducted in Buffalo, New York to verify Dr. Zamboni's work correlating CCSVI with the incidence of MS.  The agenda for the conference can be found at:

Saturday, January 30, 2010

More independent evidence for CCSVI - Wow!

It looks this this Australian research (as reported by a contributor to TiMS) would point to MS as NOT being (in the first instance) an auto-immune disease because myelin cells are being killed off BEFORE there is an immune system reaction.
Investigators at the University of Sydney have published a study suggesting that the earliest activity seen in the brain in MS is the destruction of cells that make myelin (oligodendrocytes), occurring before the onset of immune activity usually blamed for triggering the disease. This provocative study, co-funded by many sources including the National MS Society, opens up new possibilities for finding the cause of the disease and developing new treatments.

Current Study: For this study, the team used brain specimens from 11 people who had died early in the course of their MS, and the team also used comparison specimens from people with other disorders including stroke. Some of the tests focused on subsets of specimens from seven people who had lesions showing active myelin destruction. To get a sense of immune cell activity in the brain and at what stage it was occurring, the team examined newly active and resolved lesions, as well as nearby blood vessels, surrounding areas showing some disease activity and surrounding areas that appeared normal, and areas that were farther away from the lesions of interest.

Results: In tissues surrounding newly forming lesions, the investigators found evidence of the loss of oligodendrocytes with an absence of immune T or B cells that would normally be held responsible for launching the immune attack against oligodendrocytes and the myelin they produce. These and other immune cells, including scavenger cells (macrophages and microglia), were more numerous in lesions and surrounding tissues at apparently later stages of destruction and sometimes in lesions that were in the process of repair. In specimens from two very early cases of clinical onset of disease, they found few immune cells within the lesions and no evidence of activation of scavenger cells.

These and other unexpected findings from this study led the investigators to propose that the early immune activity seen in active lesions is that of macrophages and microglia, whose job it is to clean up and remove damaged myelin. They propose that lesion formation is caused by something other than destructive immune activity led by inflammatory cells against a component of myelin or oligodendrocytes.

Do i hear CCSVI in between those lines. What am thinking is that the buildup of iron, which is quite poisonous to the oligodendrocytes, causes them to die, hence lesions forming. It is then the the scavenger cells (microglia and macrophages) come in to cleanup the dead cell matter. Yes there's still a T-cell component as iron buildup will promote inflammation but probably even more damage is done by just the iron buildup.

What do you guys think?

I got this at:
This would support the idea that MS is primarily a vascular disease that causes the build-up of iron, which in turn destroys myelin (and brain cells).  Immune cells attacking our own bodies may have little to do with it, or are a secondary (or should I say tertiary) phase of disease.  Wow!

Friday, January 29, 2010

MS Resource Centre in the UK

The MSRC in the UK has launched a section on CCSVI, which is one more indication that this theory is becoming more accepted by the unbiased mainstream as a possible explanation for the initiation of MS:
New Chronic Cerebrospinal Venous Insufficiency - CCSVI section launched on the MSRC website -
Who is MSRC?  In their own words:
The Multiple Sclerosis Resource Centre (MSRC) is a proactive and innovative charity, passionately committed to supporting anyone affected by Multiple Sclerosis through access to unbiased information and advice. Our approach is to encourage individuals to make choices that are appropriate to their daily lives, empowering them to maximise their potential.

Thursday, January 28, 2010

Liberation treatment price increase in Poland

A TiMS contributor who is going to see Dr. Simka in February described a letter he received today:
I received a letter from Dr S's office outlining a change to the previous arrangement...see below:

Katowice, 21 January 2010

Dear Sirs,

We kindly inform you that due to increased costs of medical insurance and costs of clinical researches, we have to change the price of Liberation Treatment (CCSVI) method. New price also includes transportation and part of accommodation costs during your stay in Poland. We have decided to cover non-medical areas with our assistance to increase performance of the Clinic and to shorten the waiting time for the procedure.

Since 25th January 2010 the costs will amount to:
 6 900 euro : angioplasty with stenting – 1 stent (if more than one stent is placed, each additional stent costs 500 euro)
 6 400 euro : angioplasty

The price includes:
 Vascular surgeon/angiologist consultation
 Color Doppler ultrasound examination
 MRI examination
 Endovascular procedure (angioplasty or stenting)
 introductory consultation with the leading doctor
 5-night stay in 4-star hotel (breakfast included)
 Transportation to the examination and procedure facilities (Doppler, MRI, surgery)
 Transportation from/to Pyrzowice (Katowice) or Balice (Krak√≥w) Airport
 EuroMedic personnel assist during your stay
 telephone hot-line assistance

 If for medical reasons angioplasty or stenting cannot be performed the package price amounts to:
 2 700 euro : Full diagnostics with phlebography
1 800 euro : color Doppler ultrasound and MRI examination

Best regards,

Tomasz Ludyga
Director of EuroMedic
Specialist Clinics

It appears that Dr S is leaving the admin side of the treatment to others. There now is a Patient coordinator, Marta Cyba, and I believe her email is: Note that price now includes 5 nights hotel, transport to and from both Katowice and Krakow airports to the hotel, as well as to the medical facilities. Price has increased. I will be going Feb 10, so will give my observations on how things work out.

It isn't a surprise, really, and not just because it's a supply and demand issue.  When it was just one of the services done by the clinic on an as-required basis, it was being administered by the doctors themselves and the clinic didn't worry about special insurance. Now that it's become so huge (long waiting list, world-wide clientele, high profile), it doesn't make sense for doctors to be doing admin duties any more so they're adding staff which adds to the overhead and getting "insured up" since some of the patients will be coming from places where the first reaction to complications is to sue.  One of the prices of success, I guess.

Tuesday, January 26, 2010

Confirmation of CCSVI

A Consensus Conference on Venous Malformations - headed by Prof. Byung B Lee from Georgetown - and experts from 47 countries- studied the evidence and unanimously voted in favour of officially including the stenosing lesions found in CCSVI in the new Consensus document and Guidelines.
Although I wasn't able to access the source articles referred to in the Facebook page, it would appear that this should be taken as more expert opinion that there is significant evidence of causal links between CCSVI and MS.  The Facebook story says:
This paper can be brought/linked to interventional radiologists and vascular surgeons. CCSVI lesions are classified as a truncular venous malformations - which means that vascular doctors have now classified this disease, CCSVI, as congenital- and preceding MS lesions.

Vascular doctors have agreed. CCSVI comes first.

 However, since I haven't read the articles I don't know if they are quite as conclusive as that.

Thursday, January 21, 2010

Still another liberation treatment site in Poland

A TiMS contributor who had the liberation treatment done by Dr. Simka (with good, immediate results) indicated that she had heard of a third location in Poland that will be offering CCSVI screening and liberation treatments in the next few months:
There will be one more clinic in Warsaw openning as far as know end of Feb and early April.
They are already open for booking procedures.
i would recommend not to wait and contact them.
here is the contact to the new clinic in Warsaw:

However, some other TiMS participants urged caution since nobody seemed to know much about the place or their competence.  One suggestion was to ask Dr. Simka what he thought of the Warsaw clinic.

Sunday, January 17, 2010

Other Liberation Treatment Doctors

Here is further confirmation that there is at least one other doctor in Poland (a protege of Dr. Simka) is starting to do CCSVI assessments and Liberation treatments:
hi Fiddler,
here is what i received from Dr. Kostecki last week. i have not heard back from him since.

Dear Ceci
We can do test for CCSVI ( Colour Doppler Ultrasound and MRI) and endovascular procedure if necessary.
I wll give you more information soon,
Jacek Kostecki

so i say he is doing it all.
What i am trying to figure out is how many times? I am on Simka's waiting list for May, but if Kostecki could do it sooner- i might just go for it.


I will post again right when i hear from him again Very Happy

Saturday, January 16, 2010

Suggested wording of letter to doctors

Here is the suggested wording (slightly altered by me) for a letter developed by TiMS contributor GetActve to send to appropriate local doctors (perhaps especially interventional radiologists and/or vascular specialists):

Dear Doctor XXX,

As you might have heard the newest idea for MS treatment/cause is Chronic Cerebrospinal Venous Insufficiency. I have included an article from the MSAA's medical director about the idea (see link for a copy of the article). There is a lot of research going on about this right now.

It was so interesting to read today about the history of this research, starting in 1860 when a doctor said MS was a venous disease. Of special interest to me is the research of Dr. Putnam where he actually produced MS type lesions in dogs (1935) by compressing veins. He then tried to treat MS with blood thinners unsuccessfully, and his ideas were dropped as others have spent the last 70 years treating MS as an immune system disease.

Please consider treating these vein problems as Dr. Dake at Stanford and doctors in Albany NY, Italy and Poland have been doing. This is going to be a huge thing for the interventional radiologists to be involved in!


Friday, January 15, 2010

Other Liberation Treatments Possibilities in Poland and Bulgaria?

A recent TiMS posting suggests that there will be another clinic in Poland and one in Bulgaria doing CCSVI assessment and liberation treatment.  If that's the case, then some folks who missed out on getting in early with Dr. Simka would have another chance to get it checked out and done sooner rather than later.  However, I thought Kosteckj was only doing assessments and I know nothing about Grozdinski.
hi Squibbles,
Here you go... (massive waiting list!) (accepting patients from April)

good luck!

Doppler, MRV and Venography - When, why?

An Italian TiMS reader who can't get her CCSVI assessment done in Italy (how ironic - apparently there are some kinds of "political problems") posted this concise and darn clear description of the various methods for assessing veins:
Just to clarify the differences of exams and definitions:

1.Eco-color doppler of extra-endocranical veins (in particular azygos and jugular veins are checked, since most commonly blood flow problems found there for MS.). The machine is a standard doppler machine as used for cardiovascular examinations (only that there they generally check arteries), and for the CCSVI test applied to MS patients a specific computer program is required and the examiner needs to know precisely which veins to look at.

2. MRV => Definition: The type of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) used to visualize veins, the blood vessels that bring blood from the body's internal organs back into the systemic circulation.
The MRV uses the same machine as an MRI, but a special computer software allows it to only extract generated-by-blood images, as it flows through the veins. These images give doctors a rough idea of whether blood flow through a vein of interest is affected by blood clots or other disease processes.

=> Both 1+2 can either be separately or in combination used for a first CCSVI diagnosis. Zamboni used No 1.

3. Angiography - am confused about definitions on this term (I first thought called Venography), but seems that Simka is using an invasive technique to check the veins from inside in more detail? I understand that it is performed after diagnosis to check then the specific affected problem veins, to give more precise details on those, which are required for a following vein intervention.

4. The intervention process to eg enlarge the veins and potentially place some stents.

=> Simka does them all 4 one after the other to get a full picture. But for diagnosis only - to know if you have CCSVI - one of the 3 first should be sufficient.


 So, still a bit of confusion, but otherwise very helpful.

Wednesday, January 13, 2010

Protocols to give to doctors

Here is some information that could be provided by MSers to interventional radiologists, vascular surgeons, neurologists and family doctors who are interested in learning more about diagnosing CCSVI.  If anyone knows of other or better links, please let me know.

Dr. Haacke's protocol for detecting CCSVI when using MRI/MRV:

Dr. Simka's protocol for Doppler Ultrasound is here: Simka Doppler protocol link and a paper describing the same here:

Another site is which contains the following info (perhaps including links to Zamboni's protocols):
What should I give my neurologist?
Last modified: 13.09.2009 - 08:35 CET
I would like to inform my neurologist about CCSVI. What should I give him or her?
We recommend you give your neurologist the following material:
  1. The PDF files of the bold written articles of
    should be printed (the PDF links are at the end of the line),
  2. the research foundation
    should be mentioned since there are all the important articles of Prof. Zamboni listed,
  3. and the information of the Bologna conference (08.09.2009)
    Program (PDF)
    Press release (Word)
    should be printed out.
Optionally, a link to this website could be added, as there are other important links listed and the site is regularly updated.
And a later addition (though perhaps a duplicate of other information):

What I don't have here yet is a nice, brief but clear summary of what CCSVI is and why it might be a primary cause of MS.  Can someone point me to their favorite summary? 

Sharon, a TiMS contributor, suggests:
The MSAA article written by Dr. Jack Burks is a very concise summary of CCSVI plus it is written by a well known and respected neurologist. I have suggested that folks use it, especially when going to their own neurologists.
Though it might be nice to have an objective article written by someone who recognizes that an MSer who is failing fast should perhaps not be dissuaded from having CCSVI assessment and intervention, this article should be quite useful, especially considering who it was written by.

Tuesday, January 12, 2010

Loobie's Liberation Treatment Blog

A well-written and very personal blog by someone who's had the Liberation Treatment, has improved significantly, but still wishes for more:  It's easy to imagine myself in the same situation: rejoicing about the improvements, but impatient that the improvements have slowed down or stopped - while recognizing that many would love to be in that situation.

Saturday, January 9, 2010

Getting up to speed on CCSVI is probably the best place to get information about the background and recent developments concerning CCSVI and the liberation treatment, but is such a huge and growing site that "newbies" are overwhelmed.  They do have "stickies" (permanent topics) on the first page that are meant to summarize information in several category areas (the best info is usually in postings in the first few pages of the sticky thread, which are updated by the authour, usually the moderator).  However, there is much more valid information in the various threads than is contained in the stickies.  For someone who is new to the site, I would suggest first reading a few pages of each sticky, getting familiar with the issues and lingo, then use the "Search" link that is at the top of each page to search for more information concerning issues or to search for all postings by a particular authour.  For example, it is very enlightening to follow the postings of GiCi, an Italian cardiac surgeon in the UK who has had MS since 1986, had the liberation treatment for his jugulars done by Dr. Zamboni about three years ago, and then another treatment again in Belfast in 2009.

Another site that newbies might prefer is the facebook site  This one might be especially good for people who are new to the topic of CCSVI, but are used to using Facebook.

Later: Thanks to SammyJo for pointing me towards her website, which has lots of information about CCSVI and links to many other sources, as well as her own personal story about her liberation treatment at the Stanford Hospital Medical Center.

Friday, January 8, 2010

Good news

I got some good news today.  A Polish-born colleague said that he would probably be able to come along with us to act as a translator/facilitator which will be very helpful, especially if there are complications.  This will ease the concerns my wife has about such an eventuality and, besides, it'll be fun to have him along.

Wednesday, January 6, 2010

Complications: Medicare and Private Insurance

I received some information from the New Brunswick Medicare people this morning.  Basically, NB Medicare will pay for overseas “emergency” care up to $100 per day for hospital stays and NB rates for doctor’s emergency care. However, I wasn't able to find out about any specific criteria for what constitutes an emergency.  Rather, I would have to make the case for it being an emergency if some complications came up after the procedure and the case I make would be assessed on its merits.

Remember, each province’s health care rules are different, so I suggest other Canadians look on their province's health system web site to see if there is something there, or call their Medicare people.

In any case, the NB Medicare people strongly recommended that I get the private medical insurance (which will also only pay for emergency care), but I’m going to wait until I have dates for the procedure in Poland before I apply for the insurance.

Finally, while I can’t imagine why I would need extra care unless it was an emergency, and Dr. Simka seemed to imply that the Euromedic outfit he worked for would cover emergency care for something they directly caused, it must be stressed that if something DOES happen, the case for it being emergency care has to be made to both Medicare and the insurance company.

One other issue mentioned by the NB Medicare people, as an aside, was that it is reasonable to have confidence in the Polish health care system should an emergency arise.  My own experience with European health care (in Spain) is that a) it is good and b) they won't turn you away even if you can't prove that your health insurance will pay up.

Tuesday, January 5, 2010

Hearsay confirmation of CCSVI and MS correlation

More hearsay confirmation, but closer to home, is this TiMS posting from a newbie in Barrie Ontario:
The technologist said that every patient she has seen with MS (around 40 people), had blocked veins. I just called my family doc and their office has called - Dr. Sandy McDonald (resident vascular surgeon), wants to see me. The next step, if he orders it, will be a CAT scan Venograpy at the hospital here. After that all bets are off, regarding the surgery. But I won't wait around here forever. If I have to go to California I will.
In a reply in that discussion I suggested to him:
 Hi Shiraz,

I'm happy for you and to hear what is happening in Barrie, but I think that it is REALLY important to get some quoted statistics from the radiology department regarding how many MS patients they have tested for CCSVI and how many have been found with it. "Up until January 3rd, 2010, thirty-eight MS patients have been tested for CCSVI by Doppler ultrasound in the XXXX hospital radiology department and 36 have been found the condition" is much stronger than "A radiology technician told me that about 40 MS patients have been tested and all were found to have occlusions" because the latter sounds more like hearsay that can be easily dismissed.

I think that this is important for all MSers (we could take this to doctors, neuros, media), but perhaps especially for our friends in the US who seem to be battling a semi-hostile MS society and a disinterested media. A few hard facts would be harder to refute and easier to build stories around.

Now I just wish that more Canadian doctors and radiology departments would hear about this and begin taking CCSVI and MS seriously.  With such overwhelming evidence (if it is accurate), they would realize that waiting for double-blind testing is not really necessary - or ethical.

Confusion and conspiracy theories

I've been reading (and sometimes been involved in) several discussion threads lately that shows how confusing and complex the whole issue of CCSVI is, particularly with respect to MS.  Some MSers have been to get Doppler ultrasounds and/or MRVs only to be told that no occlusions were found.  Strange as it may sound to sound to someone outside the loop, that was very disappointing to them  The thing is, in those cases where no stenoses or occlusions were found, it seems that perhaps the people running the equipment may not know what to look for... CCSVI is not always easy to find, because finding them takes some training and experience.  Tied in with that is confusion about how many occlusions people should expect to find in MSers, with numbers as high 100% from proponents and as low as 1% from a technician in Montreal who did a Doppler ultrasound where no problems were found (though the technician didn't seem to be aware that an intercranial doppler ultrsound requires a special technique, and the azygous can't be assessed using the Doppler).

Felow MSer Shelley has sent me some kinks to several interesting stories.  In of one MSer who did get assessed by a clinic in Barrie, Ontario, they did find occlusions and a vascular surgeon may be convinced to do some corrective measures, which means we would have a place in Canada to go to soon.

Other things of interest include the possibility of developing artificial arteries (and perhaps veins?) so that stents would not be needed - see copy of story below that Shelley sent to me - I don't know the source.

Shelley also sent me a link to an article in a US newspaper talking about MSers getting paranoid (possibly for some good reasons) that the US media is burying the CCSVI story: On the TiMS Forum there is worry that crying "conspiracy" too loudly will get CCSVI proponents labeled nut-cases, but certainly many are wondering why CCSVI isn't getting the media exposure in the US as it is in Canada and Europe.

Artificial artery is set to be tested in human trials early this year

London's Royal Free Hospital used nanotechnology to develop the small bypass graft from a polymer material.The material enables the graft to mimic the natural pulsing of human blood vessels, which enables them to deliver nutrients to the body's tissues. The ultimate aim is to use the graft in coronary artery and lower-limb arterial surgery, which doctors say could reduce amputations and heart attacks. If the trials - funded by a grant of £500,000 - are successful, the device could potentially help thousands of patients with vascular disease.

The wall of the artery is designed to be able to withstand blood pressure throughout a person's lifetime and is normally very strong. If it is damaged by disease such as hardening of the arteries, the artery can become blocked or in some patients the wall can weaken, becoming an aneurysm, and it may rupture.
The current surgical treatment is to bypass or replace the damaged vessel using a plastic graft or preferably a vein taken from the patient's own leg. But many patients do not have suitable veins. The plastic grafts were originally made with the same nylon used to make "drip-dry" shirts. But although they work well for larger grafts, they are less successful for grafts of less than 8mm. This is because these materials cannot pulse and their surfaces stimulate clotting of the blood in the graft.

Lives lost
Researcher Professor George Hamilton said: "There is a high failure rate using these rigid, small diameter bypass grafts. Many patients who have needed smaller bypass grafts, but have not had suitable veins, have had limbs amputated and some patients unable to have coronary bypass surgery have had heart attacks and died."

The new artificial artery has been designed to mimic the natural version as closely as possible. It is strong, flexible, resistant to blood clotting and pulses rhythmically to match the beat of the heart. Using nanotechnology, the researchers incorporated specific microscopic molecules into the graft. Some aid circulation, while others encourage specialised stem cells to coat its lining, boosting its ability to repair damaged blood vessels still further. Professor Hamilton said: "This will be hugely beneficial to patients in the NHS as we will be able to reduce heart attacks, reduce amputations and ultimately save lives."

In the long-term, the team hope to develop a range of "off the shelf" grafts, stents and other devices. Judy O'Sullivan, of the British Heart Foundation, said: "We welcome this interesting development which could potentially be of enormous benefits to patients who need a bypass operation to treat their coronary heart disease.

"The availability of suitable artificial arterial grafts would mean that more patients could benefit from the bypass operation whilst avoiding having a wound following removal of a patient's own veins or arteries to be used as grafts, as current practice requires."